Daily Californian Article on Tyrone Hayes Raises Questions on Frogs, Fibs and Scientific Method

Monday, November 15, 2010
By Sue Schulte , Director of Communications
Kansas Corn Growers Association and Kansas Grain Sorghum Producers Association

Nov. 15, 2010--Berkeley anti-atrazine research Tyrone Hayes was featured in today’s issue of The Daily Californian, the independent newspaper of the University of California-Berkeley. The article outlines Hayes’ research that claims atrazine in extremely small amounts, sterilizes and feminizes male frogs. It also documents Hayes’ ongoing fights with Syngenta Crop Protection, the main manufacturer of atrazine. Atrazine is a herbicide used on corn, sorghum, sugar cane and other crops.

In the article, Hayes “strongly refuted” claims that he has not shared data on his atrazine research with the Environmental Protection Agency. The article quotes one researcher who says Hayes' research hasn't been replicated, and another researcher who says that is irrelevant.

Reproducibility
Yale University professor David Skelly, a researcher who participated in two EPA panels that reviewed the results of atrazine studies, told the newspaper that his is not aware of anyone who has been able to replicate Hayes’ results. The concept of being able to replicate the results of research is called “reproducibility”.

But that’s not relevant, according to Gail Prins, physiology professor at University of Illinois at Chicago. She told the Daily Californian that it is not important that others have not been able to replicate Hayes’ study results. She said she trusts his methods. However, reproducibility is widely recognized as one of the main principles of the scientific method (unless Gail Prins trusts you).

Missing Data?
Syngenta toxicologist Tim Pastoor told the newspaper that Hayes’ results will not be considered reliable until he gives his raw data to EPA to evaluate. Hayes hasn’t done that. Hayes’ responded by saying that allegation is “blatantly false” and told the newspaper that he had allowed EPA into his laboratory in 2002.

In a June 18, 2010 article written by Alex Avery of the Center for Global Food Issues, titled “EPA Exposes Hayes--Again!” documents Hayes’ failure to provide proper data to EPA (information excerpted below).

2005: Anne E. Lindsay, then-deputy director of the EPA’s Office of Pesticide Programs, gave Hayes a hard review in testimony before the Minnesota House of Representatives in 2005. Lindsay said EPA had never seen the results from any independent investigator published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, or the raw data from Hayes’ additional experiments. Hayes’ responded to Lindsay’s remarks in a paper recently put out by anti-pesticide activist organization, PANNA, refuting Lindsay’s 2005 testimony by pointing to a 2002 letter from EPA’s Tom Steeger praising him for sharing raw data.

2010: Illinois State Representative Dave Winters asked EPA recently if the agency had received “a complete, transparent set of raw data which could be interpreted and analyzed by the EPA and used in generating a full evaluation of his work.” Donald Brady, Director of the Environmental Fate and Effects Division replied: “I regret that the EPA science staff in the Office of Pesticide Programs’ EFED could not properly account for the sample sizes and study design reportedly used by the Berkeley researchers. As a result, we were unable to complete any independent analysis to support the study’s conclusions.”

Bottom Line
Dr. Hayes’ research can’t be replicated. He won’t share his data, even with EPA. He is a self-described anti-atrazine activist, bringing his objectivity into question. It is hard to ignore these facts when considering his claims against atrazine. Let’s hope EPA still believes in the scientific process.

19 comments:

  • sam

    It was very interesting for me to read that blog. Thanks the author for it. I like such topics and everything that is connected to them. I would like to read more soon.

    1977 Ford LTD AC Compressor

  • jon

    Its really a wonderful post. Keep it up.


    Generic Viagra

  • Admin

    Excellent Work, thank you for making this blog real and good work for the blogger.

    Search Engine Optimization Solutions

  • Admin

    You have done a Great job, keep doing more work like this ! Thanks.

    Engineering Logo

  • Admin

    This is a great inspiring .I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. I am looking to reading your next post. Logo Design

  • Admin

    Wow its totally a unique dress designs really very impressive. Facebook Timeline

  • Admin

    Thanks for sharing helpful information, I really like your all post. I will bookmark your blog for future updates. Developers BlackBerry

  • Admin

    Your sharing is meaningful. Have a good day.Thank you. Logo Design Discussion

  • Syed Faizan

    This is an awesome blog and a great source to get updated by some of the greatest facts. The work you did in order to implement this is absolutely magnificent. Pakistani Celebrity

  • Allen Perry

    Valuable info. Fortunate me I discovered your website unintentionally, and I am stunned why this twist of fate didn’t came about in advance! I bookmarked it. Roatan Excursions

  • Iftekhar Ahmed

    I stumbles the post, that are beneficial, and your post is one of them.
    Water Filters

  • alex

    Thanks for sharing helpful information, I really like your all post. I will bookmark your blog for future updates.
    Convert psd to wordpress

  • Felix Smith

    I am very happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that is at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this greatest doc. Umrah Packages
    Economy Umrah Packages
    Family Umrah Packages

  • Felix Smith

    This is a awesome and informative news for the students. Umrah Packages

  • Felix Smith

    Nice post. I like the way you start and then conclude your thoughts. Thanks for this information .I really appreciate your work, keep it up and thanks for sharing information with me. Used Police Cars

  • Mia Smith

    There was recently been unbelievably encouraged to discover this site. It is because this is actually this specific educative write-up. Dawn Travels
    Hajj Packages
    Umrah Packages

  • Truthseeker

    Read a little truth: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2014/02/10/140210fa_fact_aviv?currentPage=all

    To all you running this sham blog, you should be ashamed of yourself. Syngenta pays off an economist to say that removing atrazine would harm the ecomony. Syngenta line your pockets too?

  • Post a Comment